OPINION: Hold Open Space District’s Feet to the Fire on Existing Umunhum Tower Options

Fate of Cold War relic, Mt. Um's radar tower, to be decided Oct. 17. Reader urges support for preserving "The Cube."

On Oct. 17, the Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District will make their final decision on the fate of the historic landmark Mt. Umunhum radar tower.  The three options they have on the table are: 1 – tower removal, 2 – partial removal down to first floor walls (no ceiling), and 3 – “Retain and Seal”. 

Option 3 is what the landslide majority of bay area residents are urging the District Board to vote for. More importantly, however, there should not be any other options introduced at the proverbial “11th hour” on the night of the 17th. 

In the Board agenda minutes from July 25, one Director questioned whether a fourth option could be considered where the radar tower is fenced off and exclude people from going near it. Discussion ensued.”

This fourth option should not be allowed by any means. This option cheats the public out of the true experience of what the tower’s history has to offer. It also means that by fencing it off, the District doesn’t have to “seal” the tower per their contractor’s recommendation for Option 3. A contractor indicated that by grouting and epoxying the existing cracks and damage from Mother Nature and by sealing the doors/vents/openings, the tower would be even more structurally sound than it is today. It already passes all county and state structural stability requirements due to its design to withstand the percussion of an atomic detonation as well as the 85.5 ton weight of the antenna sail above.

Leaving the tower fenced off “as is” (since its paint was already stripped off after the hazardous material remediation) would leave it susceptible to accelerated damage from moisture and freeze damage on the unprotected concrete.

This evasive fourth option also means the District will more than likely come back after their attempted 2014 bond measure (worth nearly $100M dollars) and try to tear it down after 2014. Think about it, why would they spend money repairing a tower they want removed? Because they don’t want to and they still want it removed and Options 1 and 2 would generate too much negative publicity for their bond measure efforts.

The solution is plain to see and the Santa Clara County Historical Heritage Commission (HHC) is urging them to keep the tower. If the District elects Option 3 (retain and seal), they should play their cards smart and initiate the designation process to get the tower placed on the county historic landmark register. If successful there (and the HHC seems to want it that way), then the tower would be eligible for grant funding to renovate/repair it as a historic landmark. 

In addition to the main radar tower, the other two elements that easily fall into the historic landmark status are the smaller height finder radar tower and the 100-man underground bomb shelter. The height finder tower worked in concert with the main search radar tower and matches the same historic landmark categorization. These towers are perhaps the finest and most in-tact remaining example of a Cold War radar “set” in the entire country and even beyond. The bomb shelter is the only one of its kind in the county and should be retained and sealed for future use as a Cold War exhibit park attraction.

All these attractions atop the summit of Mt. Umunhum should be owned and maintained by County Parks, not Midpen. Midpen can own the land and maintain the trails, benches, and parking lots, but the County enjoys a steady stream of funding for parks and recreation facilities which deem them more than capable of managing that aspect of Mt. Umunhum and making it a revenue generating entity.

Basim S. Jaber, a lifelong South Bay resident, is the historian and archivist of the Almaden Air Force Station, organizing reunions of veterans who served there and gives public presentations on the history of the radar station.

Basim Jaber October 09, 2012 at 01:33 PM
Date/time/location of next public meeting where the Open Space Board of Directors will make their final decision on the fate of the tower. Wednesday, October 17, 2012 at 7:00 p.m. Historic Del Monte Building 100 S. Murphy Avenue Sunnyvale, CA 94087
Susan October 09, 2012 at 05:13 PM
I respect and understand sentimental value, and have cried my share of tears when parts of our heritage were torn down by progress. But I'm in favor of removing the cube, installing an exhibit, and restoring the majesty of the mountain. Mount Umunhum Cleanup & Restoration http://www.openspace.org/plans_projects/mt_umunhum.asp
Dave October 10, 2012 at 05:50 AM
I believe the issue goes beyond someones sentimental feelings toward the tower. The issue is regional historical significant and whether Midpen has done their due diligence to determine the towers historical value? The Santa Clara Historical Heritage Commission is urging Midpen to save the tower; that should mean something . Midpen has owned the tower and the property that surrounds it since 1986; why the sudden rush to tear it down?
Basim Jaber October 15, 2012 at 03:47 AM
Is Midpen expecting us to sink or swim? No help/cooperation from them? This needs clarification. Telling tower proponents to basically "put up or shut up" and giving us "5 years" to do it is not a solution. There's no "nolo contendre" in this. Scott Herhold's latest... http://www.mercurynews.com/scott-herhold/ci_21764133 Interim Actions still "flawed", though. http://sammydee.net/blog/uncategorized/umunhum-endgame
Basim Jaber October 15, 2012 at 05:48 PM
Letter from Santa Clara County Historic Heritage Commission to MROSD urging them to keep the Mt. Umunhum Radar Tower. http://www.almadenafs.org/docs/2_HHC-letter-to-MROSD_Oct-9-2012.pdf


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »